How to Appeal a Denied Medical Claim: A Step-by-Step Guide for Small Practices

By Eligra · · 4 min read

An appeal is a formal request asking a payer to review and change its decision on a claim. Many practices skip appeals because they take time. But appeals often succeed. This guide shows when to appeal, what to send, and how the Medicare appeal process works.

Should you appeal or resubmit?

First, decide if the claim needs an appeal at all.

  • Resubmit a corrected claim when the denial came from your own error, such as a wrong member ID or code. A corrected claim is usually faster than an appeal.
  • Appeal when you believe the payer made the wrong decision, for example a medical necessity or coverage denial where your records support the service.

Read the denial reason code and the remark codes on the remittance advice before you choose.

Why appeals are worth filing

Few denials are challenged, but challenges often work:

  • In Medicare Advantage, only 11.5% of denied prior authorization requests were appealed in 2024. Of those appeals, 80.7% were partly or fully overturned (KFF, January 2026).
  • In ACA Marketplace plans on HealthCare.gov, fewer than 1% of denied claims were appealed in 2024 (KFF, March 2026). Those were mostly consumer appeals, not practice resubmissions.

These figures cover specific programs, not every payer. They do not predict the result of any single appeal.

Step-by-step: how to appeal a denied claim

Step 1: Check the deadline

Write down the appeal deadline the day the denial arrives. For Medicare fee-for-service, the first-level appeal must be filed within 120 days of the date you get the remittance advice (CMS, MLN006562). Commercial payers set their own deadlines in the provider manual and your contract.

Step 2: Find the exact reason

Use the claim adjustment reason code and remark codes. Call or check the portal if the reason is unclear. You cannot win an appeal if you argue the wrong point.

Step 3: Gather the evidence

Collect what answers the denial reason:

  • The visit note and any test results
  • The prior authorization number and approval, if there was one
  • The payer's own coverage policy, if it supports the service
  • A letter of medical necessity, signed by the treating provider, for medical necessity denials

Step 4: Write a short, clear appeal letter

A good appeal letter:

  1. Names the patient, member ID, claim number, date of service and amount.
  2. States what you are asking for: payment of the claim.
  3. Explains in a few sentences why the denial is wrong, pointing to the evidence.
  4. Lists the attached documents.

Keep it to one page if you can. Reviewers read many letters.

Step 5: Submit the right way

Use the payer's required form and channel: portal, fax or mail. For Medicare redeterminations, use the form or format your Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) requires. Keep proof of the date you sent it.

Step 6: Track and follow up

Add a follow-up date. Medicare contractors generally decide a redetermination within 60 days of getting the request (CMS, MLN006562). If you hear nothing by your follow-up date, check status.

The five levels of Medicare appeals

Medicare Parts A and B have five appeal levels (CMS, MLN006562, September 2025):

Level Who decides Deadline to file
1. Redetermination Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) 120 days from receipt of the remittance advice
2. Reconsideration Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC) 180 days from the redetermination notice
3. Hearing Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals (OMHA), an administrative law judge or attorney adjudicator 60 days from the reconsideration decision
4. Council review Medicare Appeals Council 60 days from the OMHA decision
5. Judicial review U.S. District Court 60 days from the Council decision

Levels 3 and 5 require a minimum dollar amount in dispute, which CMS adjusts each year (CMS, MLN006562). Check the current amount before you file at those levels.

A party can name a representative, including an attorney, to act for them in an appeal (CMS, MLN006562).

Commercial and Medicaid appeals

Commercial plans and state Medicaid programs set their own appeal steps and deadlines. Most have at least one internal appeal level. Find the rules in:

  • The payer's provider manual
  • Your contract with the payer
  • Your state Medicaid agency's provider manual

Keep a one-page cheat sheet for your top five payers: deadline, form, address or portal, and phone number.

Common appeal mistakes

  • Missing the deadline
  • Arguing the wrong denial reason
  • Sending the full chart instead of the pages that matter
  • Not following up after sending
  • Appealing a claim that only needed a correction

Make appeals a weekly habit

Appeals work best as part of a steady routine, not a once-a-quarter cleanup. See denial management for small practices for a simple weekly plan.

Get early access to Eligra

Eligra is building a tool that drafts appeal letters and corrected claims for your team to review, and tracks every deadline. Your team approves each appeal before it goes out. Join the waitlist for early access.

Sources